The 10 Best Painters in Lancaster, PA (2026)
Ranked from public customer review data: each company's average Google rating, weighted by how many customers have reviewed them — so a strong rating across hundreds of jobs beats a perfect score from a handful. No company paid to appear here, and payment can't move a company up this list. Updated July 2026.
- Top rated#1 in Lancaster1
Photo: Lapp Cabinet Coatings LLC
Lapp Cabinet Coatings LLC
5.0· 142 Google reviews
2021A Horseshoe Rd, Lancaster, PA 17602
- Runner-up#2 in Lancaster2
Photo: Painting with a Twist
Painting with a Twist
4.9· 687 Google reviews
124 S Centerville Rd, Lancaster, PA 17603
- Third#3 in Lancaster3
Photo: Premium Finish Inc
Premium Finish Inc
4.9· 431 Google reviews
1208 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster, PA 17603
- 4
Photo: Benji's Painting
Benji's Painting
4.9· 199 Google reviews
84 Michael Ct, Ephrata, PA 17522
- 5
Photo: Grauer's Paint & Decorating | A Benjamin Moore Paint Retailer
Grauer's Paint & Decorating | A Benjamin Moore Paint Retailer
4.9· 197 Google reviews
1941 Lincoln Hwy E, Lancaster, PA 17602
- 6
Photo: Erica Colon Makeup Artistry
Erica Colon Makeup Artistry
5.0· 55 Google reviews
313 W Liberty St Ste e, Lancaster, PA 17603
- 7
Photo: Phillips Paint & Decorating Center
Phillips Paint & Decorating Center
4.8· 157 Google reviews
136 S Centerville Rd, Lancaster, PA 17603
- 8
Photo: Pastor John Murray
Lancaster Art Vault
5.0· 33 Google reviews
100 N Queen St 1st Floor, Lancaster, PA 17603
- 9
Photo: F&M Painting Co.
F&M Painting Co.
4.8· 103 Google reviews
179 W Main St, Leola, PA 17540
- 10
Photo: Board & Brush Creative Studio - Lancaster
Board & Brush Creative Studio - Lancaster
4.9· 42 Google reviews
1343 Fruitville Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601
Want us to do the calling for you?
Tell us about the job and we'll match you with a local painting company — free for homeowners.
Get matched with a local painting companyFrequently asked questions
How were these painters chosen?
We rank every painting company we track in the Lancaster area using public customer review data — the average star rating weighted by how many customers have reviewed the company. A high rating across hundreds of reviews outranks a perfect score from a handful. No company can pay for a higher position.
Can a company pay to be on this list?
No. Editorial rankings are computed from review data and are never for sale. When a company partners with us to receive customer referrals, we label it clearly as a partner — and that partnership never changes its position in the ranked list.
How do I get matched with a painting company in Lancaster?
Use our free match form. Tell us about the job and we'll connect you with a local painting company — there's no cost to homeowners.
How often is this list updated?
We refresh the underlying review data periodically, and positions shift as companies earn new reviews.
More Lancaster rankings
Painters in other cities
Ratings and review counts come from publicly available Google review data as of our latest refresh and may differ from what you see today. If you own one of these businesses and want to update your listing, email hello@homeguidehelp.com.